The hypothesis: If there is less new supply coming online but the demand remains at a similar level, then there is a rationale—as is the case with any commodity—for the supply/demand balance to exert upward pressure on the price.
Historically, there has been significant price appreciation following halving events, but this has not been “immediate.” We have seen three halving events so far, and we also caution any investor that the past is not an exact guide to the future—we recognize that we do not know with certainty what may happen after this fourth halving.
Two of the last three halving events saw delayed price appreciation in bitcoin. In figure 1, there is a reason why the chart is showing the behavior of the bitcoin price over a period roughly 1,000 days post-halving, which would equate to something like 2.5 years. We do this predominantly in recognition that bitcoin’s price volatility is very high, so looking at things over any short-term horizon makes it difficult to glean any worthwhile insights. Over the short term:
- Many different macroeconomic variables can influence the price of bitcoin. For example, in 2024, many riskier, more speculative assets are trading in a manner where prices appreciate when interest rates are expected to fall, and prices fall when interest rates are expected to rise.
- Over a longer time, the fact that bitcoin is known as a “hard” asset—meaning no entity can increase the supply on a whim—can have a bigger influence. We know that the supply of fiat currencies can be increased whenever the respective governments decide to do so—so the further printing of money plus the degree of debt and deficits currently employed by Western governments can have a bigger impact on driving bitcoin’s price higher—but these details would likely have little to no influence in shorter time horizons.
To keep things in context, bitcoin closed just under $67,000 on the halving date of April 20, not too far from the current price of $63,000 as of the time of writing.
Figure 1: Bitcoin Price Performance Post Historical Halving Events
Sources: Glassnode, WisdomTree, as of 6/26/24. Rebased to 1 in from halving date. The vertical red bar indicates where we are as of June 26,
2024. Each halving date is different, but the chart is measuring roughly 1,000 days after each halving event, except for the most recent, where we
are limited only to what can be seen up to June 26, 2024. Bitcoin is highly speculative and involves a high degree of risk, including the
potential for loss of the entire investment. An investment in bitcoin involves significant risks (including the potential for quick,
large losses) and may not be suitable for all investors.
Challenges for Miners
Bitcoin is a network, and bitcoin miners perform an important function to secure the network and ensure its capability to run effectively as designed. If one is looking at bitcoin, one should also understand the basics in terms of how miners are incentivized.
It is often reported that the bitcoin network requires a lot of electricity. It is the miners who are paying for that electricity in order to run specialized hardware designed to solve the bitcoin protocol, securing the network and creating the new blocks in the blockchain. In a sense, the electricity or energy is the cost, and the block reward is the revenue.
A halving of the block reward for the general miner, all else being equal, means potentially less revenue per block mined. We say “potentially” because if bitcoin’s price is appreciating quickly, the value of 3.125 bitcoin (the reward) can be higher. The number of bitcoin in the reward is constantly up until the next halving, but the price per bitcoin is not. On the other hand, the price of electricity is market-driven and largely dependent on where the mining operation is located.
If bitcoin’s price is not appreciating quickly and electricity is expensive, it is possible that the general miner, with a lower block reward, will see their profit margin compress or even disappear. This does not mean that miners immediately go out of business, but it is important to keep the general economics in mind as we all continue to watch how the market evolves.
Post-Halving Mining Industry Developments
May’s bitcoin production saw a decrease compared to April due to the reduction in rewards resulting from the halving. Breaking this down in figure 2:
- Bitdeer, Marathon Digital, Iris Energy, Cleanspark, Bitfarms, Riot Platforms and Terawulf are all major mining operations.
- When we see that Bitdeer is associated with a -31%, this means that the supply of bitcoin that Bitdeer was able to mine in May 2024 relative to April 2024 was 31% lower. Each of the other numbers in figure 2 can be interpreted analogously.
Figure 2: May 2024 Month-over-Month Production of Bitcoin (BTC)
Sources: WisdomTree, Blockworks, https://blockworks.co/news/who-mined-most-btc-since-bitcoin-halving. These seven miners were shown
due to data availability. Bitcoin is highly speculative and involves a high degree of risk, including the potential for loss of the entire
investment. An investment in bitcoin involves significant risks (including the potential for quick, large losses) and may not be
suitable for all investors.
The miners are responding to the challenges that they are currently facing.
- Mergers and Acquisitions Activity: The sector is seeing increased M&A activity, best exemplified by Riot Platforms’ attempted hostile takeover of Bitfarms.1 This is arguing for the path of greater scale leading to a better ability for miners to weather the storm of greater pressure on their potential profit margins.
- Operational Efficiency Focus: Mining firms are investing in improved computing infrastructure to improve their hash rate,2 increasing their chances of success in receiving block rewards. If we think of M&A activity leading to individual miners with bigger operations—more systems designed to generate those new blocks—then increasing the hash rate could be interpreted as getting more out of each piece of hardware.
- Diversification of Revenue Streams: Companies like Terawulf and Iris Energy are exploring new avenues, such as offering their computing infrastructure for AI model training, capitalizing on high demand in this sector.3,4 This is very interesting, recognizing that bitcoin mining is really just one application for an accelerated computing platform, and it could be interesting if certain firms can dial up or dial down their exposure to something like training AI models during times when this could be a better source of revenue than bitcoin mining.
There is a notable divergence in performance within the mining space. Well-capitalized and efficient firms are better positioned to thrive in an increasingly competitive ecosystem. Those that have been nimble and quick to adjust to the changing market dynamics have so far outperformed their peers.
In figure 3, we see how the miners shown in figure 2 have done in terms of share price performance over the past three months. Bitcoin mining company share price performance, we should note, can be extremely volatile, but we show these figures predominantly to emphasize that different miners have been able to respond differently to a challenging set of circumstances.
Figure 3: Three-Month Share Price Performance of Respective Bitcoin Miners
Source: Bloomberg, as of 6/26/24. These seven minders were shown due to data availability. Bitcoin is highly speculative and involves a high
degree of risk, includingthe potential for loss of the entire investment. An investment in bitcoin involves significant risks (including
the potential for quick, large losses) and may not be suitable for all investors.
Conclusion
As we navigate the post-halving landscape, consider a long-term perspective. Historical patterns suggest that significant price appreciation may not be immediate but has tended to evolve over several months following the halving event. Bitcoin’s deflationary nature and transparent monetary policy make it a compelling, in our opinion, with each halving event presenting an opportunistic entry point into the asset class due to the supply constraints it introduces, which has historically led to upward pricing pressure over the course of the following two-and-a-half years.
As a result of this event, the bitcoin mining industry is adapting, with efficient and innovative firms poised for growth ahead, amidst increased pressure from reduced bitcoin block rewards. While patience is required in the short term, the long-term prospects for bitcoin and the mining sector remain promising.
2 A measure of computational power that is being used to mine and process transactions on a proof-of-work blockchain, such as bitcoin.
Important Risks Related to this Article
Crypto assets, such as bitcoin and ether, are complex, generally exhibit extreme price volatility and unpredictability, and should be viewed as highly speculative assets. Crypto assets are frequently referred to as crypto “currencies,” but they typically operate without central authority or banks, are not backed by any government or issuing entity (i.e., no right of recourse), have no government or insurance protections, are not legal tender and have limited or no usability as compared to fiat currencies. Federal, state or foreign governments may restrict the use, transfer, exchange and value of crypto assets, and regulation in the U.S. and worldwide is still developing.
Crypto asset exchanges and/or settlement facilities may stop operating, permanently shut down or experience issues due to security breaches, fraud, insolvency, market manipulation, market surveillance, KYC/AML (know your customer/anti-money laundering) procedures, noncompliance with applicable rules and regulations, technical glitches, hackers, malware or other reasons, which could negatively impact the price of any cryptocurrency traded on such exchanges or reliant on a settlement facility or otherwise may prevent access or use of the crypto asset. Crypto assets can experience unique events, such as forks or airdrops, which can impact the value and functionality of the crypto asset. Crypto asset transactions are generally irreversible, which means that a crypto asset may be unrecoverable in instances where: (i) it is sent to an incorrect address, (ii) the incorrect amount is sent or (iii) transactions are made fraudulently from an account. A crypto asset may decline in popularity, acceptance or use, thereby impairing its price, and the price of a crypto asset may also be impacted by the transactions of a small number of holders of such crypto asset. Crypto assets may be difficult to value, and valuations, even for the same crypto asset, may differ significantly by pricing source or otherwise be suspect due to market fragmentation, illiquidity, volatility and the potential for manipulation. Crypto assets generally rely on blockchain technology, and blockchain technology is a relatively new and untested technology that operates as a distributed ledger. Blockchain systems could be subject to internet connectivity disruptions, consensus failures or cybersecurity attacks, and the date or time that you initiate a transaction may be different than when it is recorded on the blockchain. Access to a given blockchain requires an individualized key, which, if compromised, could result in loss due to theft, destruction or inaccessibility. In addition, different crypto assets exhibit different characteristics, use cases and risk profiles. Information provided by WisdomTree regarding digital assets, crypto assets or blockchain networks should not be considered or relied upon as investment or other advice or as a recommendation from WisdomTree, including regarding the use or suitability of any particular digital asset, crypto asset, blockchain network or any particular strategy.
]]>
